Thursday, 11 September 2014

A2: Conflicting Theories

Accumulation Theory
The view that the impact of any one message on any specific person may be minimal, but consistent, persistent, and corroborated (between media) messages result in minor changes among audiences that gradually add up over time to produce significant changes in society or culture.
Propositions
1. The mass media begin to focus their attention on and transmit messages about a specific topic (some problem, situation, or issue).
2. Over an extended period, they continue to do so in a relatively consistent and persistent way and their presentations corroborate each other.
3. Individual members of the public increasingly become aware of these messages and, on a person-by-person basis, a growing comprehension develops of the interpretations of the topic presented by the media.
4. Increasing comprehension of the messages regarding the topic supplied by the media begins to form (or modify) the meanings, beliefs, and attitudes that serve as guides to behaviour for members of the audience.
5. Thus, minor individual-by-individual changes accumulate and new beliefs and attitudes slowly emerge to provide significant changes in forms of appropriate behaviour related to the topic.


Uses & Gratifications Theory


The concept that an individual chooses which media products that they consume based upon their preferences and how they use the media. This means that people will not be susceptible to the gradual implications of change because they can choose to ignore that piece of media or take information from other media products to challenge the consistent and persistent view.


Applying to the Topic
Originally disabilities were viewed as something socially wrong rather than a genetic product. It may be that the media has changed this view as over the years disability has been treated with significantly more respect and regard. The first theory argues this, stating that gradual exposure to those hwo are disabled has allowed for an overall shift in views. The latter, however, argues that people have the opportunity to choose which media they use and how they use it, thus media has not caused an overall shift in view.